哈姆雷特：到底是什么毁灭了他？

mu · 发表于 2005-12-10 15:46

是命运吗？大家的意见如何

egmont · 发表于 2005-12-10 16:45

Hamlet巨有青年人多愁善感的范~~喜欢.俺要是说是性格决定命运,是不是靠谱啊?

Hamlet要是从知道真相开始,就冷静有预谋的展开复仇计划,就是基督山伯爵,也自然不会毁灭.

殇卿 · 发表于 2005-12-13 09:44

我觉得是仇恨！

子非我 · 发表于 2005-12-17 11:20

在戏剧当中（尤其是古典的），任何毁灭，或者相反的结局都可以归于命运，但具体到Hamlet，更直接的原因还在于他优柔寡断，悲观忧郁的性格。甚至于，如果把他的性格前置，他最后的结局根本算不上是毁灭，对于那了断后永远安歇的奇怪向往，不是在他向自己提出那个著名问题的时候就有了么？

蔓荼 · 发表于 2006-1-17 20:31

时代的悲剧啊

AKNA · 发表于 2006-1-21 21:37

是他自己
他坚持要毁了一切
他自然也包括于一切之中

jocelynxu · 发表于 2006-7-17 23:36

maybe his personality makes him meet his doom,in my opinion.

mu · 发表于 2006-7-18 08:29

原帖由 jocelynxu 于 2006-7-17 23:36 发表
maybe his personality makes him meet his doom,in my opinion.

Then what's his "doomed personality"?

jocelynxu · 发表于 2006-7-18 17:19

That his hesitation,melancholy,ect. makes him caught in dilemma in the course of his decision on the risk of his life. He seems to have the only choice,----- to die. In Hamlet (Act 3,Scene1,lines 55-86)
he finally chooses to take the responsible for his people and nation,but it is still easy for to see his hesitation as well as the so-called modern- like melancholy.

北溟之鸟 · 发表于 2006-7-20 15:38

命运
还有更好的解释吗

哈姆雷特：到底是什么毁灭了他？

the doomed personality,to some degree

hesitation,melancholy,~~~